Few American novels put off the general reader like Herman Melville’s Moby Dick. And the general reader isn’t entirely wrong to be put off.
Moby Dick is a genuinely strange work of art. For a book published in 1851, it’s more modernist text than 19th-century story, and might actually qualify as the first existentialist novel, if you take the White Whale to be the embodiment of a meaningless and hostile universe. Moby Dick is dense and it is difficult.
But it’s not as dense or as difficult as its reputation. It’s a pretty good sea-faring yarn. And it is a FUNNY book, at least until Ahab stomps onto the deck of the Pequod and sucks all the humor out of Ishmael and Queequeg, and the voyage in general, with his doomed, megalomaniac pursuit of revenge.
Now, there is some heavy going in this Melville novel and the first-time reader trying to decide how to read Moby Dick might choose to conserve his or her resources by “skimming” selected chapters. Father Mapple is a famous character, but Chapter 8 (“The Pulpit”) and Chapter 9 (“The Sermon”) could deter anyone from reading further for fear of discovering much much more of the same.
The many expository chapters, in which Melville discourses at length on every possible topic related to whales and whaling, also pose a problem for those picking up the novel for the first time.
To skip these chapters entirely would be to abstain from many of Moby Dick’s pleasures, particularly since Ishmael’s jaunty comic voice adds an agreeable tone of parody to these chapters.
At the same, there are a lot of them, and Melville is not always brief. So new readers would do well to pick and choose among chapters as they make their way through the book. For example, Chapter 32 (“Cetology”) and Chapter 42 (“The Whiteness of the Whale”) in their concentration and length are prime candidates for reading at a later date.
Which is not to say you should never read them. One of the great advantages of Moby Dick is that first-timers will do little violence to their understanding of the book’s story if they don’t read it straight through. Many of the chapters can stand on their own, inviting you to dip into the book where and as the mood possesses you. It also allows you to assemble your understanding of Moby Dick piece by piece, as if it were a 500-page jigsaw puzzle, rather than make a grimly determined march from the first page through to the last.
Finally, a copy of Moby Dick that includes reference materials is a big help. The Norton Critical Edition of Moby Dick includes maps, a glossary of nautical terms, and explanations of whaling and whalecraft with illustrations, all of which make Herman Melville’s book easier and more enjoyable to read.
I couldn’t disagree more with skipping chapters. Moby Dick is my FAVORITE novel, and the chapters you propose to skip are more than a sermon on whaling. For example, in a figurative sense “the whiteness of the whale” is a commentary on whiteness in America. Never skip, never skip, never skip. Cherish, suck the marrow from each line, and have some patience.
Of course, as I said, you shouldn’t skip them entirely: only that you should consider skipping them the first time through if you are finding the book heavy going. I’ve actually had strangers come up to me when I’ve been reading Moby in public (yes, I’m one of those people) and say the book is too long, too dull, and too hard. I don’t think any of those things are true but I also think the that “beginners” might need a little help. For example, I like to read “Chowder” to people who say they don’t want to read Moby. The usually find it funny, and then change their minds about trying it. I can’t tell you how many actually have tried it, however. Thanks for stopping by and taking the time to comment! P.
It certainly is heavy going at times, but I think its reputation as difficult is wildly exaggerated.